top of page

Review: Pride & Prejudice* (*Sort Of) (Richmond Theatre/UK Tour)

7 minutes ago
5 min read

Review by Seth Wilby


⭐⭐⭐


There are some pieces of art which are fundamental cornerstones of British culture. One of which is, objectively, Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice. Subject to numerous adaptations, it seems as if we should’ve seen it all, yet, following its premiere in Glasgow in 2018, Pride and Prejudice* (*sort of) quickly became an adaptation that was part of the theatre canon, transferring to the West End’s Criterion Theatre in 2021, where it won the Olivier Award for Best Entertainment or Comedy Play (with two further nominations) and proceeded to have numerous UK tours. Having somehow evaded the play for the best part of a decade, I was keen to experience it for myself, and find out whether the hype was sense or sensationalised.  



First published in 1813, Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice follows the Bennet family, members of the landed gentry in Regency England, as they pursue title, marriage, and wealth. Specifically, we focus on the five Bennet sisters whose only job is to marry rich, since their father has no sons (a bit like the Schuyler Sisters, in similarly colour-coded dresses but with less emphasis on misplaced commas); due to nineteenth-century misogyny, the only way his family can inherit a future upon his death is for one of his daughters to marry. It’s a complex love story, with more ghosting, slow burns, and hard launches than a secondary school group chat, filled with nuance and themes of prejudice, hierarchy, and virtue. So, clearly, it’s a logical choice to adapt into a two-act, five-performer comedy…sort of.


Isobel McArthur’s play begins how all the best shows should, with cleaning the heads of the bald men in the audience (Les Mis take notes). For this is no ordinary Pride & Prejudice, but a retelling of the story by those who are always lurking in the background- the servants. The *Sort Of in the title does a lot of heavy lifting in this adaptation that’s fresh, chaotic, and always entertaining. What I found most admirable about McArthur’s script is the ease with which she conveys Austen’s story. I’ll admit that I wasn’t overly familiar with the source material beforehand, but McArthur’s writing is such that it feels inclusive of both newbies and keen Austenites. Seeming to stick loyally to the framework of the novel, each narrative thread feels justly explained and explored, with the occasional use of narration very helpful in filling in any gaps.



A lot of the comedy is pleasantly jolly, rather than riotous, with the play possessing the spirit of a fringe show- it feels rough and handmade, but that all becomes part of its charm. Despite probably being funnier in concept than execution, the direction, also by McArthur, proves thoroughly and assuredly entertaining, with frantic multi-rolling and a smooth pace that remains engaging and exciting, and some of McArthur's gags are geniusly well-written. The modern references, from Tesco bags to cans of Irn-Bru, don’t feel shoehorned in, but work neatly within the 21st-century language of a show that, ambiguous in when it is set, never takes itself too seriously.


Before the pace picks up in the second half, it seems slightly as if the play doesn’t feel comfortable enough in its own identity. While the actual plot is compelling and well-executed, with the central love stories holding surprising weight, the comedy, although well integrated, never reaches its full potential- the audience takes too long to get on side, some of the lines don’t land, and it needs at least one scene that spirals into uncontrollable laughter in order to feel complete. However, none of this detracts from what is an undoubtedly entertaining production. There are minimal dramatic stakes, or concrete messages that arise from its concept, but that’s okay. It’s pleasant, it’s quaint, and it's an easy watch to leave you feeling cosy.



One of this production’s most unique features is the karaoke-like inclusion of pop songs, given Bridgerton-esque classical reworkings and sung with a boombox and handheld microphones. With tunes including ‘Everyday I Write the Book’, ‘The Lady in Red’, and ‘Holding Out for a Hero’, they provide some variety and nicely convey the show’s entertaining tone, without veering overly close to pantomime territory. The moments where the cast play instruments (from glockenspiel to accordion) are particularly nice; however, the songs often aren’t energetic enough, in composition or choreography, to become the attention-seeking moments they deserve. I also feel that the script could do with updating these to more modern songs, in order to generate a more enthusiastic response and properly transform this into a pop-infused, contemporary Austen twist.


McArthur’s direction seems considered, and has almost certainly benefited from so many years of development, with some of her small touches creating my favourite comic moments. Ana Inés Jabares-Pita’s design matches the vision nicely, with a pleasantly pastel set of a simple staircase and bookshelf utilised nicely, although the set and props used for this tour are notably less lavish than you’d expect from the setting, and do detract from the overall immersion. Also unfortunate was the decision not to mic the cast during spoken scenes, which left too many moments struggling to engage, especially with some of the funnier lines, and really did detract from the show’s impact.



The cast perform this complicated show fluently, particularly excelling in concrete characterisations amidst the multi-rolling. Eva Hope makes for a sweet and sensitive Jane, which totally contrasts with her brash Lady Catherine and cocksure Mr Wickham, and Georgia May Firth’s Elizabeth is a compelling and fully-fledged protagonist. Roxanne Morgan knows exactly when to exaggerate her portrayal of both Charles and Miss Bingley, as well as bringing an interesting emotional subplot to Charlotte, and understudy Emily Cruz (performing in the roles of Mary, Lydia, and Mr Gardiner on the night I attended) provided wonderfully funny caricatures, often the punchline in any scene she was in, with the audience fully rooting for her characters every move. As Mrs Bennett and Fitzwilliam Darcy, Laura Williams was superb, and a true scene-stealer who commanded the show and was truly transformative in both her roles- move over Colin Firth, because I think Williams has founded what should be the definitive Mr Darcy.



Pride and Prejudice* (*sort of) is a pleasant and entertaining evening at the theatre, even if some of its potential feels underexplored. What’s most wonderful is that it is pure theatre, imaginative and entertaining, and, when it knows what it’s aiming for, it really works, with a fluent cast and some strong writing allowing for Austen’s narrative core to shine through. Maybe it doesn’t revolutionise the world of adaptations, but it’s entertainingly theatrical and such a comfortable watch that it’s a great way to while away an evening this winter. 


Pride and Prejudice* (*sort of) continues its UK Tour until 8th May 2027. Dates and tickets at https://prideandprejudicesortof.com/tour-dates/


Photos by Mihaela Bodlovic

bottom of page