Review: Desire Under The Elms (Almeida Theatre)
Review by Daz Gale
⭐️⭐️
It's been little more than a year since one of London's most reliable and impressive theatres, the Almeida, staged a bold and daring new take on a Eugene O'Neill classic, with Rebecca Frecknall on director duty for A Moon For The Misbegotten. While Frecknall may have now departed the Almeida for her new role at the Old Vic, her influence and style can still be seen in another O'Neill offering, Desire Under The Elms. The Almeida has a strong track record when it comes to new takes on these timeless stories, but would their latest be exactly what audiences desire, or would it all be a bit wooden?

Eugene O’Neill’s Desire Under The Elms was written in 1924, drawing elements from Greek tragedy. Initially set in New England in 1850, this production has reimagined the story to be set 50 years later in 1900 in the Deep South. Set on a family farm, Eben and his half-brothers dream of the future with Eben longing to own the farm himself. Their hopes and plans are paused when patriarch Ephraim returns with a new wife in tow. What follows is a battle of heart and mind with passions, rivalries, secrets and lies all raging.
Ebenezer Bamgboye’s adaptation does some interesting things with O’Neill’s original, with its new setting heightening the intensity through a new lens, now with an added racial element making the themes of ownership and slavery all the more powerful and poignant. This production fits into the sort of thing the Almeida Theatre has become associated with in recent years, easily fitting into the same category as new adaptations and interpretations of A Streetcar Named Desire and Cat on a Hot Tin Roof as well as the obvious comparison of A Moon For The Misbegotten. Stripping away any unnecessary distractions, a bare but protruding stage brings the audience closer than ever, with a bold albeit uncomfortable decision to have supporting cast members eyeballing the audience in close proximity before the show has even begun.

Where this production of Desire Under The Elms struggles slightly is with its own sense of identity. Its influences from Rebecca Frecknall’s signature Almeida style are clear to see, with the specific style of movement and general aesthetic all screaming one of her productions to the extent that I was surprised to learn in the interval she had no involvement in this whatsoever. There is nothing wrong with being influenced by others, or even sharing styles be it through coincidence or even subconsciously - the problem here is Bamgboye doesn’t do enough to put his own stamp on things. At times, it felt as if one of the ideas was simply to replicate what had been done and worked before as opposed to coming up with something new. While some of the choices were certainly bold and audacious, its heavy borrowing of style meant it lacked originality at times and even felt confused about where it was going.
This issue with identity was prominent in two vastly different acts. Act One had a heavy use of music in one of the show’s strongest elements and most well-executed choices. However, this all but disappears in Act Two with the three musicians sidelined for no good reason. While shows drastically changing after the interval can be quite common, the extremities made for a jarring watch, with the second Act feeling far more confused both in tone and identity. This meant that the pacing was far too slow at times, particularly as it crawled to the finish line, failing to keep me completely engaged and even at one point wishing it would just end already.

That isn’t to say Bamgboye’s production isn’t without its charms. As I previously mentioned, the use of music is an inspired touch, with a haunting opening of ‘The House of the Rising Sun’ a clever nod to what was to come. Every time singer Choolwe Laina Muntanga opened her mouth to sing, Desire Under The Elms was at its best, making the lack of music in the second act all the poorer for it. The inclusion of two spirits joining her on guitar and trumpet similarly proved riveting, making the weaker or more confused elements of the production all the more frustrating. While Frecknall’s influence is all over the movement, Rose Ryan’s movement direction still had no shortage of moments of wonder, with a contemporary-dance quality in places and an almost demonic-like presence in others that worked as a great parallel to a certain performance choice.
The sparse but effective design by Basia Bińkowska had some moments of brilliance to be found, particularly when it came to lighting effects. Jack Knowles’ lighting allowed for some unexpected effects that made the play all the more interesting, with an especially striking moment towards the end of Act One - it is this moment that the design and Bamgboye’s direction are truly in sync, showing the talents of all involved and how phenomenal Desire Under The Elms could have been had it been a bit more refined in places. Though this is far from a bad show, the disparity between it at its best and worst was larger than most.

Zackary Momoh delivers a solid performance as Eben, offering an understated approach at times, bringing smaller and quieter choices to some of the more emotional moments his character faces. This quietness creates a fascinating intensity for an intriguing and well-delivered portrayal. That quietness makes an interesting juxtaposition with Antony Byrne’s Ephraim, a larger-than-life figure whose character couldn’t be more different from Eben if it tried. Byrne ramps up how unlikeable his character is, with one particularly grotesque moment in Act Two simultaneously having me repulsed by the character but astounded by the acting. The strongest moment in Desire Under The Elms comes in a particularly tense scene between the two men in the middle of the second Act, with the finest direction of the production and two sensational performances from Momoh and Byrne.
The performance everybody will be talking about, however, is Kelly Gough as Abbie. Certainly not forgettable, her approach to the character is as big and bold as it gets and will surely elicit extreme differences of opinion between those who are blown away by what she does in the role, and those who are less enamoured. I, unfortunately, fall into the latter category. While I appreciate what she was going for, her characterisation was far too over-the-top, lacking in any sort of nuance and subtlety. The character became increasingly demonic but it went too far in one direction to the extent that it felt as if Gough was in The Exorcist as opposed to a Eugene O’Neill play. It is certainly a demanding and undoubtedly exhausting performance where Gough gives all she can, but sometimes less can be more, and she struggles to find the sweet spot to really make the more intense moments land. One key sequence towards the play’s climax should have resulted in shock and discomfort through how intense it was, but veered too far away from its intent and even drew a couple of laughs from audience members - whether this is more to do with the performance or direction is up for debate, but something about this particular interpretation of the character didn’t quite land with me, making for a disappointing watch.

At its best, Desire Under The Elms is a bold and striking production, full of good ideas. The problem is they have been inconsistently realised with the production struggling to discover its own identity, instead lurking in the shadows of similar productions that have gone before. I always admire a show that tries something different, and it is a shame that this time around it never quite got to where it needed to be. The choices are certainly big, but they don’t always land with the entire production feeling as if it could have used a bit more development. One thing is for sure - Desire Under The Elms is certainly never boring, even if it does feel a bit slow and sluggish at times. Though it is admirable in its attempts to bring something new to a Eugene O’Neill classic, the result is a confused and underbaked production that wasn’t quite what I desired.
Desire Under The Elms runs at the Almeida Theatre until 23rd December. Tickets from https://almeida.co.uk/whats-on/desire-under-the-elms/
Photos by Marc Brenner



