Review: Christmas Wonderland (Brick Lane Music Hall)
Review by Daz Gale
⭐️⭐️
It's beginning to look a lot like Christmas, and while we're still enjoying embracing ourselves in all things festive, one of London's hidden treasures is hoping to get us into the spirit with Christmas Wonderland opening at Brick Lane Music Hall. Would this production be a wonder to behold or simply leave me wondering what they were thinking?
Stepping into Brick Lane Music Hall is like stepping into another world entirely. Its beautiful decorations immerse you in a winter Wonderland, allowing for a beautiful and complete escapism. Once inside, you can forget all of life's problems and instead enjoy a seemingly simpler and less problematic time. It really feels as if this venue has been plucked from another era, with its timeless nature feeling like something my grandparents may have enjoyed and starting the event off on an incredibly high point…

Unfortunately, this is also the biggest problem with Christmas Wonderland, and it isn't one I can gloss over or dismiss. Where the venue may give the illusion that we are in a different time altogether, so too does the material… in the worst way possible. Now you can call me a Christmas snowflake all you like, but please tell me why homophobic and racist jokes as well as ones about sexual assault and suicide (yes, really) have any place in a Christmas show. People are coming to a show like Christmas Wonderland to forget life's problems, so to actually risk triggering people for nothing more than a poorly written joke nobody laughed at is not only horribly offensive, it's actually pretty disgusting.
The issue with Christmas Wonderland is it has set its sights on a very specific audience, and by that I mean a very specific generation. Jokes about some of the audience being so old that they may not make it to Christmas are made all the more unfunny by the fact the venue had attracted a more diverse audience than they had perhaps expected. Anyone under the age of 70 may find their awfully outdated references confusing, with nothing there to cater for a variety of audience members. Apparently Brick Lane Music Hall (not in Brick Lane) exists in a world where jokes about people's identities are still absolutely hilarious, seemingly out of touch with a world that has thankfully moved on. I would also argue that making racist jokes is not a good look when your show is performed by a noticeably non-diverse cast. At one point, the shockingly out of touch compere asks “Do you remember Val Doonican?”. If the answer is no, this is not the show for you.

Christmas Wonderland also suffers from a seriously underthought structure with many of the sequences outstaying their welcome. Two overlong Christmas megamixes are admittedly clever in their creation, thanks to strong arrangements from musical director Scott Hayes, perhaps the brightest star in this production, but they last so long I genuinely wondered if Christmas had been and gone. Sometimes less is more, and we really don't need ten songs in ten minutes when half would suffice. Similarly, the choice to have acts perform three numbers consecutively is very ill-advised and acts as a disservice to their talents, with each having more impact if these had been spread throughout the show rather than always performed in quick succession.
Speaking of the acts, there are doubtless talented people in the cast, with Katie Lewis impressing with multiple tap-dancing sequences, and a heavily used Andrew Robley bringing a touch of Ceilidh to proceedings. His performance managed to bring one of the highest points of the show as well as one of the lowest. A particularly peculiar medley of Andrew Lloyd Webber songs in an Irish accent seemed to only entertain one person in the room - himself. However, his finest moment came from a lovely rendition of ‘Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas’, frustratingly demonstrating how much better Christmas Wonderland could have been if it had tried a bit harder.

The performance is compered by Vincent Hayes whose history is synonymous with the venue itself after being the man to establish it. While he clearly has an abundance of charm, he was responsible for some of the more awkward moments with jokes falling flat and prolonged silence. The jokes he did tell were the aforementioned offensive ones, with material that may have been acceptable in the 1970s but has no place in 2026. Bafflingly delivering material that even Bernard Manning would say was a bit much, perhaps the kindest thing to do would be for Hayes to step aside and let somebody else host the show, as his style and failure to move with the times dragged the entire production down in a big way.
The one thing that stops Christmas Wonderland being an unsalvageable disaster is the experience itself. The gorgeous decor is a wonder to behold, with each show coming with a meal or afternoon tea bringing the tiniest bit of sparkle and joy. The question arises of how to rate a show such as this - is it for the show itself or the experience in general? If it’s the latter, it would be a much more positive review as I can’t fault the venue, the food nor the friendliness of the staff. The community aspect at the heart of the production was felt with strangers striking up conversation, all ready to enjoy what we hoped would be a show that matched the standard of the experience. That show did not arrive, with the execution of what we did eventually see letting the entire experience down.

I will add that Brick Lane Music Hall acts as a charity and does genuinely fantastic things for the community. Community is at the heart of all they do, and the mention of their outreach programme was certainly admirable. It meant the initial goodwill I had for the show before it started increased tenfold, making it that much harder to write a review - but there is no denying that with all the goodwill in the world, this particular production is a massive misfire.
This review may be especially harsh, but a show like Christmas Wonderland doesn’t have any right to exist in the modern age. That is not to say the show itself shouldn’t as the idea of a music hall in London is a refreshing and novel approach - one that should bring a sense of nostalgia and transcend all generations. However, where this production fails is in its refusal to adapt, instead continuing with aspects that detract from the talent of the performers and enjoyable moments peppered throughout.
My advice to the creatives involved would be to get with the times and realise that these horribly outdated and even bigoted attitudes have no place today - and if you don't agree with that, it's probably time for you to step off the stage. It is a shame as this beautiful venue has so much potential that was squandered by a few unforgivable choices. Unfortunately, there is absolutely nothing merry about this Christmas Wonderland, and the whole thing left me wondering who on Earth thought this was a good idea?
Christmas Wonderland plays at Brick Lane Music Hall until 19th December. Tickets from https://bricklanemusichall.co.uk/whats-on/christmas-wonderland/
Photos by Lucy Hayes



